Sunday, November 4, 2007

William Shawn, Renowned New Yorker editor - From 1952-1987

Looking at some old periodical clippings the other day I came across this gem . . . my, how times have changed ( not that there's anything wrong with that ) . .

This from Horizon Magazine, January, 1981, in an article " Still at the Drawing Board " by Andrew Feinberg . . quoting Mr. Shawn: " A cartoon that is likely to endure is one that is drawn well. " ( Now THERE'S a radical idea ! ) In other words, it's okay NOT to draw a cartoon well, it's just that it won't ENDURE . . . . What part of that DON'T you understand ? Got it? Or-r I know better . . let's reinvent the wheel . . Let's go in the opposite direction . . . Remember, now, UP is DOWN, BAD is GOOD . . . Yah-hh, got it ?

What's interesting is that William Shawn reigned for 35 years . . 10 more than the magazine's founder, Harold W. Ross . . But what the hell did THEY know about cartoons !?

Any comments ? All comments welcome. Let's hear it.

2 comments:

Mike Lynch said...

Roy, I'd love to see the whole article. Any chance of a scan? Did Shawn cite any particular cartoons as examples of enduring cartoons?

Cheers,

Mike

Roy Delgado said...

Mike, I've scanned the article and it's on the way ! It makes you wonder . . What were you THINKING ?
Who the HELL do you think you are ? ! Maybe Harold Ross AND William Shawn DIDN'T know anything about cartoons ! ? @ E# ? $ % . . all I know is, if it ain't broke, DON'T FIX IT !